Friday nights in Wisconsin are traditionally centered around the local fish fry, a weekly ritual where fried seafood temporarily becomes its own food group. On June 26, I visited Sidetracked Bar in Neenah to sample their specific fish offerings after hearing local mentions of their menu. For those looking to evaluate the local dining landscape without the usual marketing fluff, here is a breakdown of what the venue provides.
Sidetracked Bar features a parking lot large enough that you won't need to practice your parallel parking or park three blocks away, which makes arriving straightforward even during the Friday rush. The interior is clean, organized, and staffed by efficient, friendly bartenders who do not make you wait ten minutes just to order a beverage. Upon reviewing the menu, the Friday fish options cover a standard variety of choices.
June 26,2026 Pricing
Stuffed Haddock ($17.50): Haddock stuffed with crab and cheese, served on wild rice with hollandaise sauce and asparagus.
Sidetracked Combo Dinner ($17.25): A platter containing two pieces of perch, a 4 oz. haddock loin, and three butterfly shrimp.
Perch Dinner ($17.95) / Big Perch Dinner ($23.55): Generous portions of perch served with house tartar.
Haddock Dinner ($13.50) / Big Haddock Dinner ($24.00): 4 oz. loins prepared fried, baked, or with lemon pepper.
Shrimp Dinner ($13.50) / Big Shrimp Dinner ($20.50): Breaded butterfly shrimp with shrimp sauce.
Fish or Shrimp Tacos: Available as 3 tacos for $12.50 or 2 tacos for $8.75.
Perch or Haddock Sandwich ($8.95): Served on a toasted hoagie.
I ordered the Sidetracked Combo Dinner ($17.25) because choosing between perch, haddock, and shrimp is an unnecessary Friday existential crisis. The meal was prepared quickly—arriving before I could even finish a casual analysis of the bar's tap handles.
The fish itself was flakey, and the breading was light and not overly greasy. The shrimp was standard butterfly style and crisp. Each fish dinner includes coleslaw, rye bread, and a choice of fries, criss-cuts, tater tots, or a baked potato. The coleslaw was crisp and fresh, avoiding that sad, watery texture found at lesser establishments.
For the price point, the portions are fair and the overall meal is solid. Sidetracked also runs several drink specials and maintains a diverse selection of beers on tap and in coolers to handle your hydration needs. If you are looking for things to do in Neenah or exploring options for food events in Neenah, this venue offers a reliable, low-stress option for a Friday night meal.
Want your restaurant or food event featured on WiParty.com? I can shoot pro photos, create mouth-watering videos, build websites, handle marketing, and write blog articles that get eyes on your venue or menu!
